TTIP: Now More Than Ever, We Need a Common Vision for the Future

USCIB President and CEO Peter M. Robinson
USCIB President and CEO Peter M. Robinson

By Peter M. Robinson, President and CEO, United States Council for International Business (USCIB)

This column was originally published in Echanges Internationaux, the magazine of ICC France, the French national committee of the International Chamber of Commerce.

The past year has been a disappointing one for transatlantic trade policy. More than ever, we must stand up for trade and investment, two keys for economic growth and job creation. Peter M. Robinson, President and CEO of the United States Council for International Business (ICC USA), puts forward some ideas for a common transatlantic business agenda.

Efforts by the United States and the European Union to negotiate a comprehensive, high-standard Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership have progressed at a disappointingly slow pace. As we near the end of the Obama administration (and look ahead to a Trump administration that promises a decidedly different approach to trade policy), TTIP has gotten mired in squabbling over a range of challenging issues and is now effectively sidelined.

These are challenging times for global companies and for major business organizations, including the International Chamber of Commerce and its national committees – such as ICC France and USCIB.

Strong, credible voices from business are more important than ever. The U.S., France and Europe more broadly all need more economic growth, more prosperity, more and better jobs. And as we in the ICC family know, one of the best ways to drive that growth is through increased international trade and investment. With that said, I would put forward the following as a common transatlantic business agenda that we can all agree on.

Keep pushing on trade liberalization

The U.S. and EU must keep pressing ahead on the important and challenging issues in TTIP. We cannot let the change of administration in the U.S., internal divisions within the EU, or other distractions deter us or our political leaders from achieving a comprehensive, ambitious, and balanced Transatlantic economic framework. TTIP was, and remains, our preferred option but that pathway seems blocked at least for the time being. It won’t be easy, and it won’t get done as fast as we’d like. But whether TTIP or some other comparable U.S.-EU agreement, it is more important to get a great agreement than to get a quick or easy agreement.

At the same time as we work to cement transatlantic ties, the U.S. and EU also need to keep providing strong leadership for the multilateral trading system, principally through support for and leadership of the World Trade Organization, which desperately needs a strong shot in the arm. The U.S. and Europe must work together to push forward an ambitious multilateral trade agenda for as we approach the WTO ministerial in Argentina in late 2017.

Work together on development

One key element of any WTO agenda needs to be a strong development pillar, designing and implementing creative ways the WTO trade regime can more effectively promote economic growth in the least developed countries, especially in Africa.

Through our “Business for 2030” initiative, USCIB had spearheaded efforts within the ICC network to provide proactive, constructive business participation in the UN Sustainable Development Goals and the 2030 Agenda. We would love to work more closely with ICC France and other leading ICC national committees in Europe on this effort, as we did successfully on the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. Our website www.businessfor2030.org provides additional information on this important effort.

Join forces on global taxation

Business needs clear, predictable, and fair tax regimes in order to plan and execute its operations. Both European and American business need to be more active, and more closely coordinated, in our participation in the G-20 and OECD efforts to reform global taxation. ICC France and USCIB actively engaged in the OECD’s Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS). We cannot allow the BEPS effort to get hijacked by those with an anti-business agenda.

Keep global organizations “open for business”

Unfortunately, some international organizations in the UN family are becoming hostile to the private sector, seeking to exclude business representatives from key meetings and to impose an anti-business agenda. Leading U.S. and European business groups, and the global ICC network, need to confront that discrimination, while actively supporting and growing the mutually beneficial relationships that do exist after over 70 years of consultative status with various UN agencies.

I have laid out a long and challenging agenda. I very much look forward to working with François Georges and his dynamic team at ICC France in all of these important areas. We have a lot to do, and a lot more that we can do together. Let’s get to work.

Investment Facilitation – UNCTAD’s Useful Agenda For Pragmatism Over Politics

By Peter Robinson, President and CEO, United States Council for International Business

investment_buildingsWe in the international business community are, frankly, not in the habit of finding inspiration in policy papers on the sometimes politically-charged topic of international investment from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), often seen as an organization more aligned with developing country governments. But a recent UNCTAD document, UNCTAD’s Global Action Menu for Investment Facilitation, discussed at last month’s UNCTAD’s Fourteenth Ministerial Conference and, in more detail, at its parallel World Investment Forum, is a valuable contribution to ongoing policy debates on international investment in developing countries, in the U.S., European Union and around the world.

Building off of the important model of the Trade Facilitation Agreement adopted at the World Trade Organization’s ministerial meeting in Bali in December 2013 and currently in the final stages of an extended ratification process among the WTO member countries, the UNCTAD proposal for an Investment Facilitation Action Agenda eschews broad and controversial policy issues related to international investment and, instead, focuses on concrete implementation and facilitation steps which governments, developed or developing, who chose to welcome Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) can take to improve their competitiveness as an FDI destination. Out with politicized policy debates on Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) and in with practical recommendations to help governments attract more and better foreign investments and to do it more quickly and efficiently.

Read the full column at Investment Policy Central.

Telecom Giant Sunil Bharti Mittal named ICC Chairman

Mittal
Sunil Bharti Mittal

Sunil Bharti Mittal, founder and chairman of Bharti Enterprises, has been elected Chairman of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). Voting by ICC’s World Council took place today in Sao Paulo, Brazil.

Bharti Enterprises has interests in telecom, insurance, real estate, hospitality, agri and food, besides other ventures. Bharti Airtel, the group’s flagship company, is the world’s third largest telecommunications company by customer base, offering mobile, fixed broadband and digital TV solutions to over 350 million customers across India, South Asia and Africa.

“At a time when the global economy is facing unprecedented challenges I am committed to ensuring ICC plays a central role as the voice of business in shaping policies to support inclusive growth,” said Mittal, who served on the Prime Minister of India’s Council on Trade and Industry. “I am honored to be ICC’s 51st Chairman and look forward to working actively with ICC’s global network throughout the world.”

Mittal added: “There is an urgent need to restore trade and investment as a driver of growth and jobs-particularly in developing economies affected by the slowdown in raw materials and agricultural commodities markets. This will be a central focus for my tenure as Chairman of the world business organisation.”

The International Chamber of Commerce is the world’s largest business organisation with over 6.5 million members in over 130 countries. Mr Mittal becomes the third Indian Chairman of the world business organisation in its near-100 year history.

Mittal takes over the ICC Chairmanship from Terry McGraw, Chairman Emeritus of S&P Global, who becomes ICC’s Honorary Chairman.

Roberto Azevedo, director general of the World Trade Organization (WTO) paid tribute to McGraw’s leadership of ICC over the past three years saying: “Over the years, Terry has played a huge role promoting the WTO and the multilateral trade agenda as a force for good. He was instrumental in building support behind the 2013 Trade Facilitation Agreement. I thank him for what he has done for the institution and for global trade in general.”

ICC has also announced that John Denton, partner and CEO of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, has been elected to take over from Mittal as the organisation’s First Vice-Chair. ICC’s World Council has also elected three new members to its Executive Board: Anne Veronique Schlaepfer, partner at global law firm White & Case; Kok Seng Vong, vice president of the Macao Chamber of Commerce; and Philippe Varin, Chairman of the Board of Directors of AREVA.

Current Board Members Esko Aho (Nokia), Milos Barutciski (Bennett Jones) and Cherie Nursalim (GITI Group) were all elected to serve a second term.

Ending Child Labor is Everyone’s Business

Over 168 million children are still trapped in child labor around the world. As supply chains have become more increasingly complex, the risk of child labor is present in all supply chains, and all enterprises must be vigilant to ensure that their supply chains are free from child labor. Because child labor occurs largely in the informal economy in areas where law enforcement is weak or absent, abuses often go undetected. Governments must step up their efforts to tackle the problem.

The theme of this year’s World Day Against Child Labor, which took place on June 12, is ending child labor in supply chains. USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson gave introductory remarks at an event titled “End Child Labor in Supply Chains: It’s Everyone’s Business,” on June 9 at UNICEF headquarters in New York. The event was hosted by the International Labor Organization (ILO), UNICEF, the United States Fund for UNICEF and the Permanent Mission of Argentina to the United Nations. Argentinian UN Ambassador Martín García Moritán gave keynote remarks on the importance of child labor eradication.

Robinson reaffirmed USCIB’s commitment to eliminating child labor. As the International Labor Organization’s (IOE) regional vice president for North America, Robinson highlighted the many ways in which employers have contributed to the fight against child labor, including the IOE-ILO Child Labor Guiddance Tool for Business and the 2007 IOE-ILO Guides for Employers on Eliminating Child Labor. USCIB has also worked to educate companies on the tools available to address child labor in supply chains, for example through a recent webinar USCIB hosted with UNICEF.

“The IOE and its member federations play an active role both within countries and internationally in combating child labor and advocating global access to education for children around the world,” Robinson said. “We view child labor, particularly in its most dangerous and exploitative forms, as intolerable both because of its inhumanity and the negative long-term consequences for the economic and social well-being of the children concerned.”

During the event, panelists discussed best practices and approaches that companies have adopted to respect children’s rights and eliminate child labor.

“Like all of you, we in the business community view this as a shared responsibility,” Robinson concluded. “Companies at all levels must work to root out child labor from their supply chains, while states must improve accountability and governance, which, I might add, has the added benefit of improving a country’s overall investment climate.”

ICC Americas Chapters Express Support for Venezuelan Colleagues

Heads of the ICC Americas Regional Group
Heads of the ICC Americas Regional Group

Representatives of the national chapters of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in the Americas gathered to express their support for maintaining democracy and the right to free enterprise in Venezuela. As a tense situation worsens in Venezuela, over 17 business organizations – including USCIB – representing more than 1 million companies in America and Spain condemned the unjustified actions of the Venezuelan government against the private sector and the Venezuelan people.

“The actions taken by the Venezuelan government are a clear violation of basic civil rights, attacking human dignity, intimidating the population, and veiled by corruption and impunity,” the ICC chapters said in a statement. “Urgent action must be taken to create a climate of trust based on respect towards the population  that promotes stable and strong relationships that benefit the majority of Venezuelans and not only the privileged in power.”

The business organizations said Venezuela will not reach the path of development and well-being by attacking the private sector, imprisoning executives or union leaders and limiting Venezuelans’ access to their basic rights.

“In a republican government system the separation of powers is a fundamental necessity for freedom,” the statement said. “The checks and balances of a democratic system find strength and virtue in this separation so as to mitigate possible future power struggles.”

Business Mobilizes Support for Sustainable Development at OECD Forum

Robinson_OECDforum
USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson

The business community is 100 percent on board with United Nation’s 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda and wants to contribute meaningfully, USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson told the OECD Forum today, but companies need a stable and predictable policy environment in which to operate.

Held in Paris every year to coincide with the OECD Ministerial Council Meeting, the theme of which this year is “Enhancing Productivity for Inclusive Growth,” the OECD Forum has emerged as a major international conference. Leaders from all sectors of society, including former and current heads of state, CEOs, leaders of key NGOs and trade unions and prominent members of academia and media, gather to debate the most pressing social and economic challenges confronting society.

Robinson participated in a panel on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and spoke about the private sector’s contributions to the global community’s objectives (full program here). The SDG agenda encompasses a wide array of inter-related economic, social and environmental issues. Governments – as well as non-governmental stakeholders – will need to adapt to new challenges and overcome intellectual and institutional silos. The business community, including USCIB, has helped to spearhead the private sector’s input to the development of the SDGs, and is working hard to mobilize and demonstrate business support around specific objectives.

“We have constructed a sophisticated platform, Business for 2030 for companies to learn how to support specific aspects of the Global Goals, and for policy makers and the development community to learn more about company projects and business initiatives in support of the SDGs,” Robinson told the audience.

A catalog of business engagement that showcases the private sector’s contributions to the SDGs, Business for 2030 features over 140 initiatives from 35 companies in over 150 countries of how businesses are helping to achieve 72 of the 169 SDG targets. The website highlights concrete initiatives and public-private partnerships to inspire renewed trust in the private sector, and to catalyze sustained and active business engagement in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.

Robinson also talked about the importance of adopting the right policy frameworks that make badly-needed investments in the developing world less risky. He said the policy tools and instruments of different international organizations, including those of the OECD, should be promoted among all countries, including the OECD’s Policy Framework for Investment (PFI) – a key checklist for policies that will encourage investment and growth in countries.

“Globally, official development assistance is dwarfed by foreign direct investment,” Robinson said. “We need to provide incentives for investment to flow where it can do the most good.”

Other speakers on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development Panel included Martine Durand (OECD), Michael Elliott (ONE), Aart de Geus (Bertelsmann Stiftung), Alenka Smerkloji (Minister for Development, Slovenia), Helle Thorning-Schmidt (Save the Children International) and Peter Turkson (Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace).

The OECD Forum runs from May 31 to June 1 in Paris. USCIB is the U.S. affiliate of the Business and Industry Advisory Committee (BIAC) to the OECD. More information on the forum is available at the OECD’s website.

Read more: “10 Business Recommendations for Productivity, Prosperity and Inclusive Growth,” BIAC Statement to the OECD Ministerial Council Meeting 2016

Enhancing Productivity for Inclusive Growth

USCIB CEO Peter Robinson, BIAC Secretary General Bernhard Welschke, and BIAC Innovation & Technology Committee Chair Rick Johnson at the MCM Consultation (Santiago)
USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson, BIAC Secretary General Bernhard Welschke, and BIAC Innovation & Technology Committee Chair Rick Johnson at the MCM Consultation (Santiago)

“Enhancing Productivity for Inclusive Growth” will be the theme of this year’s OECD Ministerial Council meeting chaired by Chile. The Chilean government, led by the Ministers of Finance and Foreign Affairs, hosted a preparatory meeting with the Business and Industry Advisory Committee (BIAC) to the OECD on April 25 in Santiago, Chile. Fernando Alvear Artaza, the general manager of the Confederation for Production and Commerce (CPC) in Chile, presented the views of BIAC and his federation on measures to improve productivity and to better use the growth potentials of our economies.

USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson spoke on the key role of business to realize the Sustainable Development Goals. And the chair of BIAC’s Technology Committee, Rick Johnson, explained the potential of innovation and digital technologies for more growth and well-being.

The BIAC delegation was strongly enhanced by the participation of Martin Pérez Monteverde, president of the National Confederation of Private Entrepreneurial Institutions (CONFIEP), BIAC’s new observer in Peru. Following the meetings in Santiago, Martin hosted the delegation in Lima for talks with the presidents of CONFIEP member federations. The Peruvian economy and cooperation with BIAC on all OECD matters were the focus of discussions.

At the OECD Week General Assembly on May 30, BIAC will present the results of its new economic policy survey and celebrate the 40th anniversary of the OECD Declaration on International Investment and Multinational Enterprises.

Talking Up Trade in an Election Year

By Peter M. Robinson

The presidential candidates are distorting the facts about trade and jobs. We all need to push back.

USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson
USCIB President and CEO Peter Robinson

To hear many of the contenders for the White House tell it, international trade is a dead end. There have been numerous memorable quotes from both sides of the aisle that I won’t dignify by repeating here. Nearly all the candidates say the Trans-Pacific Partnership needs to be scrapped or renegotiated.

Such rhetoric, coming from politicians who use it to convince people to vote for them, is extremely disturbing. Why? Because it is distorting the facts about trade and jobs! While the anti-trade diatribes coming from the campaign trail tap into a tangible belief among many disaffected voters that trade policy and the economy in general are rigged against them, they fly in the face of a recent Gallup poll that reports that Americans continue to believe—by a wide margin, 58 to 34 percent—that international trade presents an opportunity rather than a threat.

We in the business community have a responsibility to remind people – including our political leaders – of the facts, and cut through the hyperbole. We need to speak out to help our employees, our shareholders and the communities we operate in understand that the world is growing around us, and that we cannot – nor can other countries – afford to turn inward.

Page2_GallupThe fact is, expanded trade over the past two decades has boosted annual U.S. income by about ten percent of GDP – thousands of dollars per household – relative to what would have been otherwise. A study from the Peterson Institute for International Economics says the United States stands to be a big winner – the biggest winner – from the TPP, with income gains of some $130 billion by 2030. This growth is essential if we are to meet our goals in terms of new and better jobs, and an expanded middle class.

U.S. negotiators drove a hard bargain in the TPP talks, and – while no one, including the business community, got everything they wanted – we came away with an agreement that puts our most competitive industries, and the people they employ, in a good position for strong growth in the burgeoning Asia-Pacific marketplace. This is good news for American workers, since export-oriented companies pay, on average, 18 percent higher wages than their non-exporting counterparts.

It is also important to remember that trade liberalization serves an important geopolitical role, cementing U.S. leadership and a safer, more prosperous world – one where we can address common challenges like tackling climate change, fighting terrorism and lifting people out of poverty. In today’s world, everyone benefits when America leads.

We should take anxiety over trade seriously. But the gains from an agreement like TPP far outweigh the costs. And jobs lost to trade as a result of the agreement can and should be addressed via enhanced Trade Adjustment Assistance, something the business community has long supported. We also need to acknowledge that job dislocation is being spurred by technological advances and corresponding transformative disruptions.

An important priority will be connecting necessary skills development to the jobs of tomorrow. And as World Trade Organization Director General Roberto Azevedo has observed, increased trade, by boosting income and creating better jobs, can play an important role in raising skills and reducing inequality, both within countries and across borders.

Boosting investment for the future

To meet both the opportunities and the demands of the 21st-century economy, the United States needs a comprehensive approach to invest in enhanced competitiveness. Such an approach should encompass serious efforts to improve education and training, rebuild our infrastructure, reform the tax code and improve our regulatory environment.

We also need to invest in future agreements to open up markets for American goods and services. In this regard, it is extremely important to promote open and well-functioning investment policies and regimes. Private investment, in addition to traditional trade, will be a critical factor in the years to come.

At every opportunity, USCIB has sought to demonstrate the positive economic benefits of foreign direct investment – both inbound and outbound – for the American economy. A 2013 report by Professor Matthew Slaughter of Dartmouth, commissioned by USCIB and the Business Roundtable, demonstrated convincingly that U.S. companies who grew their overseas operations to access foreign markets exported more, and provided more and better jobs at home.

USCIB is working hard to address barriers to investment abroad, both in trade agreements like TPP and international organizations that design rules of the road for their member governments. Our members continue to face policy and regulatory barriers that inhibit entry into specific markets, and impede their ability to design, produce, market and distribute their products globally. Unlocking their ability to invest and compete abroad will be critical to American success in the 21st century, leading to sustainable enterprise and job creation.

In a recent op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, Professor Slaughter and Morton Kondracke, the former executive editor of Roll Call, posed the question: “Who will step up to tell the compelling trade story that America needs to hear?”

We, for one, will. And I hope that we can count on everyone in USCIB’s membership to join us and our partners in the broader pro-trade community, in Washington and around the world, to make the case for international trade, and for investing in the future of our country.

Enabling a Vibrant Digital Economy Is Essential for 21st Century Business

Digital GlobeSeveral years ago in this column, I remarked on the amazing transition from e-commerce to the “Internet economy.” Nowadays, it is clear that the digital economy, for all intents and purposes, is the economy. Very little commerce, both in-country and across borders, could take place without the interconnected networks enabled by the global Internet. Think about how your business would function for even a day without reliable access to modern information and communication technologies (ICTs).

The OECD, which has served as an invaluable forum for discussion of sensible policy approaches to the challenges and opportunities presented by the digital economy, is gearing up for a ministerial meeting this June in Cancun, Mexico. The meeting will explore work undertaken by the OECD Committee for Digital Economy Policy to address the continued evolution of the digital economy in the eight years since a previous 2008 ministerial in Seoul, South Korea. USCIB and our members played an active role at the Seoul ministerial, where I had the privilege of serving as chair of the “business day” events.

The Seoul ministerial acknowledged the essential nature of the Internet as a platform for economic growth, and emphasized the need for all stakeholders to guide its development. Recognizing the vast changes in this area since 2008, the Cancun ministerial will highlight the extent to which the entire economy has become digitized, and explore how this transformation has affected social interactions, business and government operations, laws and regulations, and jobs and skills. Numerous USCIB and other global companies are set to participate.

Privacy and localization concerns

The Cancun ministerial comes against the backdrop of growing unease in some markets over privacy protections for cross-border data transmissions. The European Court of Justice got everyone’s attention recently when it invalidated the European Commission’s 2000 decision concerning the adequacy of the existing transatlantic “safe harbor” framework. In the past 15 years, thousands of U.S. companies have used this framework to ensure that their data practices are in line with European Union privacy rules.

Addressing the 2016 Consumer Electronics Show in January, Federal Trade Commission Chairwoman Edith Ramirez said she was confident that U.S. and EU officials would reach agreement on a new data transfer deal – a so-called Safe Harbor 2.0, which is essential for the global operations of both tech and non-tech companies. As we went to press, however, there was still no agreement, and the clock was ticking loudly toward a January 31 deadline imposed by EU Data Protection Authorities (DPAs). The DPAs indicated that if U.S. and EU negotiators do not conclude Safe Harbor 2.0 by that date, they may launch probes of U.S. tech companies to ensure compliance with European law. Such actions could have a severe chilling effect on transatlantic data flows, with potentially devastating consequences for both the U.S. and EU economies.

A related development is rising support for the forced localization of data centers within a country’s border. As USCIB members have made clear in numerous forums, such requirements diminish the investment appeal of these markets by creating undue burdens for global companies. Localization requirements also threaten ground-breaking ICT advances – with promise of significant economic and societal benefits for these countries – in such areas as cloud computing, use of Big Data and the Internet of Things. Also important (and ironic), data localization measures effectively undermine privacy and security by distracting from efforts to create better protections for individuals and generally making these markets more vulnerable to hackers.

More generally, we are seeing a proliferation of other types of localization barriers, such as local content requirements, discriminatory government procurement practices, technology transfer requirements and other policies and regulations aimed at promoting domestic industry and shielding it from foreign competition.

Wise policy choices needed

A vibrant digital economy holds great promise for individual businesses and the global economy more generally. Many countries realize this, but in their efforts to harness the innovative and developmental potential of an Internet-fueled economy, they are resorting to policies that risk quashing that vibrancy.

During last year’s review of the decade-old World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS), an initiative launched under UN auspices, we also heard calls from some countries for a stronger government role in governance of the Internet. Such an approach would undermine the bottom-up, multi-stakeholder approach to Internet governance. When governments work together with other stakeholders, we can realize significant progress in raising capacity, knowledge, and understanding of digital economy issues. Policymaking invariably is improved when representatives of business, the technical community, and civil society inform such discussions; such inclusion also helps to lower the risk of unintended consequences.

The upcoming OECD ministerial provides the perfect opportunity for the business community to tell lawmakers which policies best realize the promise of Internet-enabled development and innovation. USCIB seeks a ministerial outcome that recognizes the importance of private-sector investment and “light touch” regulation that preserves the Internet’s interoperability. We would also like to see the OECD highlight how emerging technologies facilitate economic development and address societal needs. And collaboration between all stakeholders is a must in order to expand inclusion in the digital economy.

USCIB addresses these issues at a global level through our unique role as U.S. affiliate of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) and of BIAC, the Business and Industry Advisory Committee to the OECD. We are lucky to have strong member support and leadership from individuals such as Eric Loeb (AT&T) and Joseph Alhadeff (Oracle), chair and vice chair, respectively, of our ICT Policy Committee. (Alhadeff also chairs the corresponding committees at ICC and BIAC.)

I am confident that USCIB and our members will have robust representation in Cancun. And I am equally confident that policymakers will recognize the Internet’s role as a platform for innovation, social inclusion and economic development. With your continued strong support, USCIB and our members can continue to drive industry leadership in this critical area; ICTs are essential for doing business in the 21st century.

ICC and BIAC Families and Staff Safe After Terrorists Attack Paris

Paris_peaceUSCIB is relieved to report that all Paris-based staff and their families at the International Chamber of Commerce and at the Business and Industry Advisory Committee to the OECD are safe and no USCIB staff were in the city at the time of the attacks.

Our thoughts and prayers are with the victims and families affected by the horrific series of attacks that took place in Paris last Friday and we echo what John Danilovich, ICC’s secretary general wrote on Friday, “We are united in our profound sadness and grief following the attacks.”

On Monday at the OECD and BIAC, staff observed a minute of silence for the victims and their families and friends. “It is important for us to know that we all stand together in these difficult times,” said Bernard Welschke, BIAC secretary general, in a note to members on Monday.

Francois Georges, secretary general of ICC France responded to USCIB President Peter Robinson’s note of concern with “Such a dramatic tragedy and event gives a lot of sense to ICC Founders’ message when they called themselves ‘Merchants of Peace’. It is more than ever relevant.”

ICC’s Banking Commission meetings that were originally scheduled for this week have been cancelled. At the time we posted this story, all the United Nations COP21 meetings are still scheduled to take place in Paris from November 30 to December 11.

Our hearts are with Paris in these difficult times.